MIKE
STALTER
Inexperienced. Irresponsible.
Cozying up to Anti-ICE Radicals.
Backed By Democrats.
Dangerous For Otsego County.
POLITICS OVER PUBLIC SAFETY
Mike Stalter has pledged to immediately cut off Sheriff Department cooperation with ICE and the Department of Homeland Security, as reported in AllOtsego.
Because of this, he is wholely backed by Democrats and the most anti-Cop radicals in our community.
Statements and positions taken by Stalter raise concerns about whether he is willing to work collaboratively with outside agencies when necessary to protect the community.
Public safety cannot be driven by personal politics.
https://www.allotsego.com/former-sgt-michael-stalter-announces-run-for-county-sheriff/
HISTORY OF ETHICAL AND POLICY ABUSE
Sheriffs are entrusted with enormous authority and discretion.
Voters deserve confidence that the individual holding that office consistently exercises sound judgment, follows established procedures, and places professionalism above personal interests.
A pattern of incidents and decisions throughout Stalter's career raises legitimate concerns about whether he possesses the judgment required to lead the agency.
Examples include:
• Questions surrounding adherence to reporting and documentation requirements.
• Questions regarding proper use of departmental resources and equipment.
• Questions regarding decision-making while off duty.
• Questions regarding compliance with agency policies and procedures.
• 2/8/16 - Deputy Michael Stalter answered a call at a residence in Cherry Valley, NY and there was an officer conduct report filed against Stalter.
• 6/23/20 - Misuse of government property - Stalter was off duty and had his radio in his personal mustang. He was driving with his girlfriend and heard a “shots fired” call that he was nearby. He showed up on scene in his personal vehicle, got his govt-issued AR-15 out of the trunk and his girlfriend took off in the mustang.
• 9/2/2020 – Failure to file Domestic dispute – Stalter’s Girlfriend and her sister have a domestic dispute. Girlfriend calls Coop PD. Stalter already on scene as he was called by girlfriend. Girlfriend was allegedly pushed down stairs by sister and Stalter/girlfriend went to Bassett.
• 7/22/22- Misuse of position - Girlfriend in an accident in Cooperstown. Called Stalter, not 911.
• 2/17/23 - Ran out of Gas - in pursuit of a suspect, Mr. Stalter ran out of gas in his government issued car and asked his fellow deputies to stop and pick him up – who were in pursuit as well
.jpeg)
QUESTIONS OF PERSONAL RESPONSIBILTY?
One of the most pressing issues facing Otsego County is the future of the county jail.
The New York State Commission of Correction has dramatically reduced the operational capacity of the jail due to aging infrastructure and facility concerns. The Sheriff's Office must balance public safety, inmate housing, transportation costs, staffing shortages, and state mandates.
Stalter has repeatedly suggested simplistic solutions that fail to address the reality of the situation. Simply "boarding out" inmates is expensive, logistically challenging, and can reduce local control over inmates and operations.
The next Sheriff must have a realistic plan. Wishful thinking is not a strategy.
https://www.otsegocountyny.gov/departments/a-c/county_clerk/records_search.php
DOES NOT UNDERSTAND THE OTSEGO COUNTY JAIL.
One of the most pressing issues facing Otsego County is the future of the county jail.
The New York State Commission of Correction has dramatically reduced the operational capacity of the jail due to aging infrastructure and facility concerns. The Sheriff's Office must balance public safety, inmate housing, transportation costs, staffing shortages, and state mandates.
Stalter has repeatedly suggested simplistic solutions that fail to address the reality of the situation. Simply "boarding out" inmates is expensive, logistically challenging, and can reduce local control over inmates and operations.
The next Sheriff must have a realistic plan. Wishful thinking is not a strategy.
https://www.otsegocountyny.gov/departments/s-y/sheriff_s_office/jail_condition_assessment.php
© 2026 PAID FOR BY OTSEGO GOP
Politics Over Protection
Mike Stalter has pledged to immediately cut off Sheriff Department cooperation with ICE and the Department of Homeland Security, as reported in AllOtsego.
Because of this, he is wholely backed by Democrats and the most anti-Cop radicals in our community.
Statements and positions taken by Stalter raise concerns about whether he is willing to work collaboratively with outside agencies when necessary to protect the community.
Public safety cannot be driven by personal politics.
HISTORY OF ETHICAL AND POLICY VIOLATION
Sheriffs are entrusted with enormous authority and discretion.
Voters deserve confidence that the individual holding that office consistently exercises sound judgment, follows established procedures, and places professionalism above personal interests.
A pattern of incidents and decisions throughout Stalter's career raises legitimate concerns about whether he possesses the judgment required to lead the agency.
Examples include:
• Questions surrounding adherence to reporting and documentation requirements.
• Questions regarding proper use of departmental resources and equipment.
• Questions regarding decision-making while off duty.
• Questions regarding compliance with agency policies and procedures.
.jpeg)
QUESTIONS OF PERSONAL RESPONSIBILTY?
Leadership begins with personal responsibility.
When voters evaluate a candidate for Sheriff, they have every right to ask whether that candidate demonstrates the judgment, accountability, and responsibility expected of the county's chief law enforcement officer. Especially overseeing a budget of over $160 million.
The Sheriff must serve as a role model for every deputy, correction officer, and civilian employee in the department.
Otsego County deserves a Sheriff whose record reflects the highest standards of responsibility and professionalism.
DOES NOT UNDERSTAND THE OTSEGO COUNTY JAIL
One of the most pressing issues facing Otsego County is the future of the county jail.
The New York State Commission of Correction has dramatically reduced the operational capacity of the jail due to aging infrastructure and facility concerns. The Sheriff's Office must balance public safety, inmate housing, transportation costs, staffing shortages, and state mandates.
Stalter has repeatedly suggested simplistic solutions that fail to address the reality of the situation. Simply "boarding out" inmates is expensive, logistically challenging, and can reduce local control over inmates and operations.
The next Sheriff must have a realistic plan. Wishful thinking is not a strategy.
